Skip to content
Man pointing to building blocks on a large site plan
Insights

What's a "good" deal for a First Nation?

Tim Coldwell
Tim Coldwell
What's a "good" deal for a First Nation? | Énska
2:35

A BMW pulls into the community. A guy gets out in a Canali suit, Patek Philippe on his wrist, and says, “Have I got a deal for you.” First Nations have heard that line for 150 years. The promises get broken, and some of the people making them are outright snake oil salesmen.

Plenty of non-Indigenous partners want to work with First Nations today. So what does a good deal look like?

It starts with control. Énska works only with First Nations, and our position is that the Nation holds the controlling interest in the project and controls the board, through a majority of directors or a casting vote. Outside of rare exceptions, that’s non-negotiable.

Next, count what the Nation brings. Most Nations don’t want to put community savings at risk by writing equity cheques, and they shouldn’t have to. They bring land or the right to buy it first, taxation rights, preferred financing and tax advantages, and they take risk out of a project in ways nobody else can.

So we open every conversation the same way. The capital partner puts up 100% of the equity and, if the lender needs it, 100% of the guarantees. In return, they earn a preferred return equal to the equity the Nation would have put up for its 51%. We often structure the partnership so 90% of cash flow after debt service goes to the capital partner until that pref is repaid. The other 10% covers the Nation’s cost of participating. After that, cash flow splits by ownership, with the Nation never below 51%. The Nation can also use its cash flow to buy down or buy out the partner over time. This structure has worked in a number of well-documented Canadian deals.

Then the fees. Management and performance fees are where good deals quietly go bad. We benchmark every one against the market and keep them as low as the market allows, while leaving the partnership the resources it needs to manage the project properly day to day. The principle is simple: minimize fees, maximize cash flow to the partners.

We have our own reason to get this right. Every client we have is a First Nation, and they talk to each other. Put one Nation into a bad deal and our reputation, and our business, is gone overnight. Our test: we’d be proud to see the partnership agreement on the front page of the newspaper.

So, a good deal? The Nation brings all the benefits that are uniquely theirs as a Nation to the table and owns a majority of the partnership. Its partner shows up in a good way, carries the equity and the guarantees, and gives the Nation a clear path to buy them out with the project’s own cash flow.

There’s a lot more detail underneath. That’s the shape of it.

Share this post