Skip to content
Carved and painted Indigenous figure on a cedar post-and-beam frame
Insights

Two-year elections and eight-year deals...

Tim Coldwell
Tim Coldwell
Two-year elections and eight-year deals | Énska
2:21

A large real estate or infrastructure deal takes five to ten years from first conversation to opening day. In a lot of First Nations, Chief and Council face an election every two years. Do the math. Three to five councils can touch one project before it opens.

That’s the problem. A capital partner who wants to work with a Nation in a good way needs to know that a decision made this year will still stand in five. When every election can reopen the deal, good partners walk and projects stall. Stability in decision-making comes from one place: separating politics and business.

The research backs this up. The Harvard Project on Indigenous Governance and Development has studied it for nearly 40 years. At the First Nations Major Projects Coalition conference in Toronto last year, Harvard economist Joe Kalt, on stage with Clint Davis of Cedar Leaf Capital, walked through roughly 120 First Nation enterprises. The ones run by Chief and Council had about a coin-flip chance of survival. The ones with their own board were five times more likely to stay in the black. In Saskatchewan, the Indigenous Business Toolkit from Vern Bachiu, Murray Fulton and Kristy Jackson found the same thing on the ground: dev corps work better with their own board, CEO, charter and autonomy.

You can see it in the Nations that got there first. The James Bay Cree are the OGs in Canada. CREECO, their economic development company, runs businesses like Air Creebec as businesses. In the U.S., the Seminole own Hard Rock International. The Southern Ute Growth Fund runs energy, real estate and private equity across more than a dozen states. The Navajo have built enterprises at real scale. At home, Des Nedhe Group has done it for English River First Nation.

None of this cuts the community out. Chief and Council set the vision and appoint the board. The board and management run the business.

So here’s the bottom line. If your Nation wants to use the power of business to become self-determining, you have to separate politics and business. Stand up a dev corp with professional management and an independent board, and invest in it. Do that, and the research says your businesses are five times more likely to survive. Over a generation, that’s the difference between a Nation that talks about self-determination and one that achieves it.

Share this post